Was this a blind spot by Rockstar in writing the mission as if the fishing mission had already been done? But I had to change this because during the train robbery, Arthur will mention t the gang that he has encountered Pinkerton Agents just outside of camp which is an obvious reference to "Fisher of Men." After initially paying a visit to Mr. Downes, who is sickly and poor, Arthur discovers . Before any more can be said, Susan Grimshaw shoots Molly in the stomach with a shotgun, killing her instantly. Arthur dies no matter what the player does, regardless of having high honor vs. low honor in Red Dead Redemption 2, but it does affect how Arthur dies at the end of the Red Dead Redemption mission. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. However, it is necessary to complete in this chapter if one wants a good introduction into bounty hunting side missions. Its only when Thomas wife Edith breaks up the fight, telling him that her husband is sick, that Arthur relents, but Arthur also warns them theyll have to pay the money back soon. Come RDR2, it seemed those questions would be answered. -Chapter two is the second biggest chapter, and because of that it starts to get a bit convoluted here. What did Arthur do to Edith Downes? What causes the bounty hunters and police to attack you relentlessly? Arthur later learns how Edith earned enough money to settle her husbands death. [05] [X] Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall? Quest Giver: Edith Downes (Archie Downes) Wearing masks, bandanas, just threatening him and never making him bleed? Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Edith is the wife of Thomas Downes and the mother of Archie Downes. Back to Gamorrah" should be labeled, "A Short Walk in a Pretty Town" should be labeled. To start the mission, however, you need to have your Honor rating above level 4. Probably needs to be interspersed with other missions, since Dutch would be unavailable at camp for "Magicians" until "American Distillation" gets triggered in Rhodes. Clearly, my post got messed up too. Red Dead Redemption 2 is the third series of the Red Dead Redemption game series launched in 2010. Once the player reaches rank 4, the Heros Pearl Grip for the Cattleman Revolver becomes available. I'll definitely be trying this out instead during my second playthrough. Thanks so much for posting something like this! This has more impact if it is closer to the end, because from here on out, saving John will be pretty much his only concern. Stranger Missions are side quests that can be found across the Wild Go to the mine located west of Annesburg. I've restarted chapter 2 multiple times to try and get the best RP experience out of the game. Jack is Johns son, but Arthur clearly had a massive influence on him. Yeah, that was one of the issues I was having with Chapter 6. Exactly how I play Chapter 1. I would love to have Charles and Lenny in camp (screw Micah) but not going further until I must. Depending on how players proceed, they'll be helping Edith Downes leave Annesburg only to find her in Annesburg with Arthur having never helped her at all. Arthur returns to the Downes Ranch to collect the last of the loan from her. I saw that mission on the second play through and tried to skip but I had no more missions left. Can airtags be tracked from an iMac desktop, with no iPhone? Edith's husband, Thomas, began having financial problems, so he obtained a loan from Leopold Strauss. This finishesDo Not Seek Absolution II mainmission in Red Dead Redemption 2.Nowthe next quest Of Men and Angels I starts. Your email address will not be published. As we know, spirits are high after Sean's safe return and there's no pressing need for Arthur to rush back to camp. At the end of John's train robbery (Pouring Forth Oil IV), he asks if they think they were followed and Arthur mentions that it's possible because he'd already been found near Horseshoe Overlook - however, I had NOT yetbeen confronted by the Pinkertons while fishing with Jack. To trigger it, Arthur must visit the doctor in Saint Denis, and have a high reputation (honor). Arthur later learns how Edith earned enough money to settle her husbands death. How to Unlock Do Not Seek Absolution - I: it is unlocked after completing A Fork in the Road, however you . Chapter six is the longest and easily the most convoluted section of the game. This thread contains spoilers pertaining to the story missions of Red Dead Redemption 2. Therefore, this needs to be done the day following the other money lending missions in chapter two. Just part of the story. Good work! He seems like such a small character but technically he killed Arthur Morgan by sending him on that ridiculous mission. Edith Downes quest. I tried and tested this too a couple of times, - So IN CONCLUSION it seems like'Who Is Without Sin' was meant to be done before 'The First Shall be Last'. I really screwed up in chapter 5 when you get back to America you can choose to go to a mission for Dutch or Sadie to help John (the balloon mission). I figure there's two places that it would fit as a lead-in with regards to Bill: shortly before "Short Walk", or immediately before "American Distillation". Edith's husband, Thomas, began having financial problems, so he obtained a loan from Leopold Strauss. Complete with at least 70% accuracy. Once you do, he'll give you three targets, and even if you try to get smart and only do the other two, eventually he'll remind you of Downes, and the mission begins automatically. The mission is unlocked after completing the A Fork in the Road mission. If you try to do it in the opposite order, Strauss will confront you and force the game to trigger the money lending mission. In the case of Arthur Morgan, the man that gives him tuberculosis is Thomas Downes, who he shakes down for money. Wait seriously? Since "A Short Walk in a Pretty Town" is pretty much unambiguously the start of the chapter climax and denouement,those missions' place in the timeline is cut-and-dry. Arthur wants to help Edith Downes and her son Archie in achieving a quiet life. finished at any time. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. This series of quests cannot be started until Chapter 5 and after the "A Fork in the Road" missionwhen Arthur, in Saint Denis, learns he has contracted tuberculosis is completed. To start the first mission, go to the town of Annesburg and find Edith Downes. In Sadie's mission, he asks Sadie to help the Marstons as well, which I find makes more sense if he already talks to John about escaping. Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? Reviews. EDIT: The forum merges double posts, how clever. I went back to camp and read the letter from Mary and then the cut scene with Strauss activated right after. I'll definitely be giving this a go after I'm done with my first playthrough. Arthur again offers to give them money and tells them to use it to help them start a new life somewhere. I'm not trying to insult, just trying to help. Just finished "Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego" and feels like there should be a bit of gap between now and starting "Spines of America". At some point, he started running a ranch and became a fundraiser for The Charitable Organisation of New Hanover. Also, I'm sorry about the formatting in this post. Thanks for the feedback so far! This walkthrough will guide you through all objectives of Do Not Seek Absolution - I Main Quest including all Gold Medals for 100% completion. I don't like Micah, Arthur doesn't like Micah, and I don't see that he would be in a hurry to meet up with him again. Details on missions will be hidden, so only mission names will be visible unless you wish to view details and notes. Theres no way to save Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar Games. Red Dead Redemption 2 has a total of 104 Gold Medals you can earn by completing each mission checklist. Just curious if anyone has tested different orders of main missions to maximize dialogue. And there you have it! John's line in "The Battle of Shady Belle" commenting on the futility of the deaths the gang's caused in pursuit of this feud-meddling, but specifically naming the timeframe as "the last few weeks", the same rough period as Arthur's recovery (were it to happen immediately previous) but Arthur doesn't defer, which has me going back to my initial feeling of "Peacemakers" being more of a mid-chapter break mission, then the gang has lied low enough (and Dutch and Bill have charmed their way into Sheriff Gray's continued good graces) for things to die down until they make too much trouble, but specificallytoo close to Rhodes - and that leads the Pinkertons to them, as shown in "Battle for Shady Belle". . Also, this is subjective, but there's no line even hinting that robbing the Valentine bank could screw up the ongoing plans with the Grays (only mention I saw was Arthur reminding Bill that they've 'got irons in' the Gray/Braithwaite plot already), it sort of feels to me like this comes before the meat of the Grays/Braithwaites gets started and as a capstone of 'unfinished business from Valentine' before the gang sinks their teeth into the Rhodes plot. Comment document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "eb1d0f0d1142f08341a9b2a63514f196" );document.getElementById("d386d3c936").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Crisis Core -Final Fantasy VII- Reunion Trophy Guide. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved PC Stadia Xbox One. Funny little detail, if you take the debt quest from Strauss where you have to colect a debt from a miner in Anesburg called Arthur, and if you do that quest before you meet Edith Dowens in Anesburg. How do you persuade Edith Downes? Home. What can a lawyer do if the client wants him to be acquitted of everything despite serious evidence? Make . Watch the cut-scene. is a good time to do any side missions/explore around Strawberry and West Elizabeth in general. Board Topics. However, there are three separate threads to this chapter, and mixing and matching missions from each thread can break up the cohesive narrative, so its best to do each back-to-back. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. DO NOT REVEAL BELOW IF YOU HAVE NOT COMPLETED CHAPTER VI !!! I'm pretty confused here. Plus if you meet them and it's night time then time will automatically fast forward to morning as this is meant to be a day mission. There are even missions in chapter two that wont unlock until this particular one is done iirc. No, to end chapter 2 it is necessary to catch TB from Thomas Downes. Also, in this game, players can move freely in the open world. Upd 2: "Short Walk in a Pretty Town" through "The Battle of Shady Belle". 3. Red Dead Redemption 2 Guide and Walkthrough. Edith has one of the darkest storylines of any of the side characters in Rockstar Games'Red Dead Redemption 2,and thanks to a few key moments of dialogue,players can get a prettyclear answer of what happens to the grieving widow after everything is said and done. Money Lending and Other Sins I, II, III - To finish the mission, you need to turn in the debts. What repeatable activities are the most profitable? I hope he catches pneumonia and dies in those hills. The money lending missions come first, because it seems that after Arthur realizes how evil loansharking is and how it has ruined peoples lives, he then decides not only to stop doing it, but actually help some of those whom he has hurt by loansharking in the past, like Edith Downes. Do Not Seek Absolution - 1. She and her son pack up and leave the homestead, intending to start a new life elsewhere. More. What does help though with projects like thisis that cutscenes will sort of push you in a certain direction when you have multiple missions to chase after. Directing you towards Willards Rest, its up to you to catch up to Edith and save her. And that is what this proposed mission orders aims to accomplish. Get on your horse and ride north along the railway tracks. Arthur Morgan originally encounters the Downes family in the Horseshoe Overlook chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2. Additional note - This mission allows you to increase your honor (reputation) to the maximum level. Go back with the widow to Annesburg. Story-wise, it develops Arthurs character, but gameplay-wise, it gives Arthur an excuse to travel to Saint Denis despite him as a character being resentful of such civilization. Why did Ukraine abstain from the UNHRC vote on China. After that, the game will add a quest marker in Annesburg. Arthur later helps out Ediths son Archie, keeping him from being harassed by his miner coworkers duringone ofRed Dead Redemption 2's side missions, and afterassisting the boy Archie expresses concern over his mother continuing to sell herself, despite their debt being paid off. I remember seeing a stranger mission from Edith Downes in Annesburg some time ago, but now it's gone. This isn't really a mystery or Easter egg, just optional honor missions. Only available if you completed 'Brothers and Sisters, One and All'. From my experience, there's a few bits of dialogue that repeat for each character per chapter and there's also a few bits for each one that are time sensitive. Similarly, in Chapter 2 you can get Lenny back at Horseshoe Overlook before rescuing Sean, and thus maybe get more dialogue/character development during Sean's party. Originally I had "Money Lending and Other Sins [III]" occur after "We Loved Once and True," but it turns out that the game will not allow this to happen. After Arthur saves her son from being bullied by the miners, Archie tells him that his mother refused Arthur's money and has not stopped being a prostitute. One order that sort-of makes some logical sense to me but I have no idea if it's feasible due to unlock conditions: However, after playing though it once, it becomes rather simple to piece the missions together into a more coherent and logical narrative. For example, I did not include most of the Money Lending Missions simply because I did not play them my first time around. Arthur offers to fix the problem, but she tells him to get lost. These two eventually take their leave of the Marstons, Charles allegedly up to Canada to start a new life and, while we don't know exactly where she headed off to once her injuries from the . She hugs her son and wonders what she and Archie will do. Go to the bridge / Search for a trail at the bridge / Follow the trail / Go to Edith Downes. Most of them occur at night as well, so note that you can spend the day doing other things instead of triggering the missions, and then time-skipping several hours. So, if youre planning on buying Red Dead Redemption 2s best weapons at a knockdown price, be on your best behaviour. of course Strauss knew about the illness. It just seems so weird to have this big dramatic moment with O'Driscoll, Arthur getting shot, taking weeks off to recover, having that lull time and thenanotherbig dramatic climax as the Gray/Braithwaite plot comes to a head. She and her son eventually move to Annesburg, a thriving mining town. Do Not Seek Absolution is a multi-part side mission available in Red Dead Redemption 2. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. Find Archie (he is standing between the buildings). You have to reach the path that goes under the bridge. Well spotted, its fixed now! After working as a prostitute, Edith appears to have small, rough red bumps on her face, suggesting that she may have contracted. In the Saint Denis chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur runs into her in the New Orleans-inspired city when she mistakenly tries to sell him her services before realizing who he is. My main concern here was the travel distance between mission starting points. This section lists all the Red Dead Redemption 2 Stranger Missions, optional assignments that involve colorful characters, and the time-sensitive Honor Missions.